John's Journal...
Entry 179,
Day 5
GILES ISLAND
Being A Deer Guide on Giles Island
EDITOR'S
NOTE: Chad Pugh partners with Jimmy Riley on the
Giles Island Lodge.
Question: How long have you been guiding on Giles Island?
Answer: Ten years.
Question: For what type of deer does Giles Island manage?
Answer: Trophy white-tailed bucks. A trophy is a 130-class deer with a
bow and 150 with a gun.
Question: You and I recently hunted together. Let's discuss
that deer we saw. How far was the buck when you first spotted him?
Answer: He was about 150 yards away.
Question: Tell me about his rack.
Answer: He was a tall and tight 10-point buck. His tines were probably
11 inches across. His main beam was 22 inches across. He was a typical
9-point with a sticker on his G2 that made him a 10 point.
Question:
What would he have scored?
Answer: About 140 points on the B&C scale.
Question: How much would that deer weigh?
Answer: 190 pounds.
Question: How close did he get?
Answer: Sixty yards.
Question: Why wouldn't you let me shoot that deer?
Answer: Because he had to score 150 points on the B&C scale for you to
harvest him since you were shooting a gun.
Question: Anybody would be proud with that size deer.
How old do you think he was?
Answer: Two-and-one-half years old.
Question: Tell me about the other deer we saw.
Answer: We saw another tall and tight 10-point buck. He was probably 2-1/2-years
old. He was close to 140 points. He had 11-inch tines. His G2s and G3s
were 11-inches. His G4s were probably 4-1/2 inches and 3 inches. His brow
tines were short. He was a young deer. He probably weighed 180 pounds.
Question: Why wouldn't you let me shoot that deer?
Answer: He didn't score 150 points on the B&C scale. He would have been
a shooter for a bow hunter.
Question: Why is it so hard to judge deer on Giles Island?
Why do most people need a guide?
Answer: Most people aren't familiar with scoring a deer on the hoof.
Question:
What are you looking for in a shooter deer?
Answer: Long main beams, long tines and mass. You need 4-1/2 inches at
least.
Question: How long do a buck's brow tines need to be?
Answer: About 4 inches. The spread doesn't count. That's only 10-percent
of the score. A good buck needs long beams and a heavy mass.
Question: How do you know if the deer is a shooter?
Answer: It's big. We've seen so many that we just know whether or not
they're shootable.
Question: How do you tell to shoot the 130s?
Answer: A deer must have at least 10-inch tines. You still need a long
main beam and a little bit of mass.
Question: Most people pass up bigger deer than they've
ever taken before here, right?
Answer: It's tough, I know. But it's part of the program. It's what keeps
people coming back, because they know there are big deer out there.
Question:
Why are you trying to get rid of 8 points?
Answer: Because genetically it's hard for an 8-point to score high on
the B&C system. We want our 10s and above to be breeder bucks. With a
bow hunter, we'll let you shoot a 3-1/2-year-old 8 point, regardless of
his size. If they're 8-points, they always will be. We have a deer called
White Patch that's proven that. He's 8-1/2-years old and has been an 8
point since he was 3-1/2 years old.
Question: Why do you call him White Patch?
Answer: Because he has a white, heart-shaped patch above his flank.
Question: Why are you only taking 150 point or better
bucks?
Answer: Because that's a good trophy.
Question: You see a lot of broken tines, right?
Answer: Yes. It's because they're fighting. Our buck-to-doe ratio is 1-to-1,
so there's a lot of fighting. The deer will also have a lot of scars and
scratches.
To learn more about Giles Island, write 461 Old River
Boat Camp Road, Ferriday, LA 71334, call (877) 944-5374, or visit www.gilesisland.com.
|